6 December 2021
Jonathan McAllister, University of Cambridge
Georgina Nugent-Folan, The Making of Samuel Beckett’s Company / Compagnie (Brussels: University of Antwerp Press, 2019).
Tried to get going again in English to see me through, say for company, but broke down. But must somehow.Samuel Beckett to Ruby Cohn, 3 May 1977.
One of the arguments often levelled against genetic criticism is the following: tracing the composition of an artwork tells us little about the significance of the work itself. The most concise formulation of this critique of which I know is given by the late Roger Scruton: ‘what a thing is and how it came to be are two different questions, and the answer to the second may not be the answer to the first’. For this reason, one critic has unreasonably argued that ‘genetic criticism explains nothing, and never has’. But Georgina Nugent-Folan shows that there are substantive intellectual reasons for pursuing a compositional analysis of Beckett’s work. Of relevance to my review is the processual nature of his prose, which foregrounds the pursuit and motive of reading and writing creative texts. What genetic criticism allows scholars to do is offer tentative answers to the questions of how and why we go about these strange activities.Continue reading “Book Review: The Making of Samuel Beckett’s Company/Compagnie”